of Children Online, government policies in this area are in
their infancy.260
Several countries have also devised national strategies or
developed policy frameworks which address child protection
in the light of new challenges raised by the Internet. These
often seek to combine and coordinate measures involving
various stakeholders.261 At the national level, efforts to prevent and combat such crimes also require effective interagency coordination.262
In many countries, there may be little to no legal basis for
police to take action against child abusers and exploiters if the
victim has already reached the legal age of consent, even
though the child is still under 18 years of age. Most jurisdictions still set the age of consent for sexual activity below 18
years of age, with the average ranging from 13 to 16 years.263
Importantly, some countries’ laws make the permissibility of
sexual intercourse and other related practices dependent on
the age difference between partners or on whether the partners are married, whereas others rely on notions such as gauging when a child has reached puberty. Still others do not
specify any age of consent at all. To complicate the matter
further, countries have different definitions for sexual activity,
ranging from kissing to sexual intercourse.264 The definition of
“child” in domestic legislation as well as the criminal provisions on sex crimes are critical issues in all matters relating to
child protection and combatting child sexual abuse and
exploitation.
Child sexual abuse material
Surprisingly, child sexual abuse material has come to the
attention of criminal law only comparatively recently, with
laws in countries such as England, Canada and the United
States only entering into force in the late 1970s. Laws against
child sexual abuse material in most countries are based on the
policy position that children should be protected from
See also OECD, 2012. Pp. 32-34.
In Mauritius, for instance, in order to promote the cooperation
and coordination among ministries and institutions in the field of
child protection, a protocol of collaboration for the promotion of
children’s rights and their protection against abuse, including
commercial sexual exploitation, has been signed by relevant
stakeholders. Comments from experts, Government of Mauritius,
April 2014.; see also OECD, 2012. Pp. 39-44.
262
See also OECD, 2012. P. 47.
263
ECPAT, 2008. Strengthening Laws Addressing Child Sexual
Exploitation: A Practical Guide. Pp 47-50. Available at http://www.
ecpat.net/sites/default/files/Legal_Instrument_En_Final.pdf.
264
Ibid.
commercial sexual activities because they are too young to
give informed and thus valid consent.265
States define offences related to child sexual abuse material in varying ways.266 For example, in some countries, (adult)
pornography is considered to be an offence against public
morals and decency or a violation of public order, and child
pornography is punished in that context. Other countries link
child pornography to obscenity laws that cover a wide range
of different images, only some of which may be illegal.267 A
common approach in Western and Northern countries is to
criminalize only child sexual abuse material (and not porno
graphy in general) on the basis of the age, or apparent age, of
victims.
As indicated in the Cybercrime Study, interests protected
by the criminalization of child abuse images include the protection of minors from abuse, and the disruption of commercial markets in child abuse images, that may encourage
offenders to seek to produce and supply further images.
Although international frameworks demonstrate many similarities with respect to the criminalization of child pornography, differences also relate to the object, age of children and
acts covered.268 The Cybercrime Study also found that, at the
national level, over 80 per cent of countries responding to the
Study questionnaire indicated that child pornography is a
criminal offence. The majority of countries reported that
computer-related acts are criminalized by way of a general
offence.269 As an example, in Mauritius, offences against children can be prosecuted under laws related to, inter alia, rape,
sexual intercourse with minors under the age of 16, attempts
upon chastity, sodomy, alleged sexual assault, causing a child
to be sexually abused, accessing a brothel, child abduction,
attempts upon chastity of minors under the age of 12, as well
as under the Computer Misuse and Cybercrime Act of
2003.270
260
261
Subgroup Against the Sexual Exploitation of Children, 2005.
A/HRC/12/23.
267
UNODC, 2013. 100-104; Subgroup Against the Sexual
Exploitation of Children, 2005. Pp. 29.
268
UNODC, 2014. Pp. 100-104.
269
Ibid.
270
Comments from experts, Government of Mauritius,
April 2014.
265
266
40 STUDY ON THE EFFECTS OF NEW INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES ON THE ABUSE AND EXPLOITATION OF CHILDREN