Over the past years, investments in cyber defence in the EU have increased against the
background of growing malicious cyber activities by state and non-state actors. It is critical that
the EU strengthens its cyber defence capabilities. Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine
further reinforces the need for increased investments, to ensure that Member States have stateof-the-art cyber defence capabilities, both stationary and deployable.
Technology improvements are essential to maintain an advantage over competitors and
adversaries, who are also investing heavily in new technologies. Therefore, the EU and
Member States also need to enhance their cooperation and interoperability on cyber defence
through joint capability development and increased investments in research and development.
In addition, vulnerabilities stemming from strategic dependencies and the fragmentation of the
EDTIB37 need to be addressed. In particular, skills and competences are essential to overcome
strategic dependencies on cybersecurity and cyber defence in Europe. The European defence
industry needs to retain key skills and acquire new ones to remain in a position to deliver hightech solutions in a global setting38. A lack of skills has a negative impact for the defence sector,
as it hampers capability development in all domains. All actions will be fully in line with the
approaches announced in the Synergies Action Plan, the Roadmap on critical technologies for
security and defence (‘the Roadmap’)39 and the Gaps Analysis40.
3.1. Develop full-spectrum state-of-the-art cyber defence capabilities
Member States bear the responsibility and competence to use cyber defence capabilities,
whereas the EU plays an important role in supporting the further development of specific
military capabilities across the Doctrine, Organisation, Training, Materiel, Personnel,
Leadership, Facilities and Interoperability (DOTMLPF-I) spectrum to create freedom of action
in cyberspace. There is a need to unify further the approach to cyber defence across all
capability domains and to adapt it to the changing geopolitical environment. It is therefore
necessary to identify the missing elements in existing capabilities and support the development
of new capabilities in a coordinated and measurable manner.
However, the level of engagement of Member States in collaborative cyber defence
development projects remains insufficient to date and should be increased to maximise the
impact at the EU level. All Member States must increase their investments in developing fullspectrum cyber defence capabilities and develop these in a collaborative manner. Member
States should consider developing a set of voluntary commitments for the development of
national cyber defence capabilities, also multinational capabilities beyond existing PESCO
cyber defence projects41. The Coordinated Annual Review on Defence (CARD) process could
be used to start a dialogue with Member States on cyber defence requirements and national
37
E.g. as identified in the Defence Investment Gaps Analysis
Several initiatives have been launched, e.g. the European Defence Skills Partnership.
39
The Commission in the Roadmap on critical technologies called to reinforce cooperation on technologies that
are critical for Europe’s long-term security and defence and efforts to reduce related strategic dependencies.
40
The Joint Communication on the Defence Investment Gaps Analysis and Way Forward where the Commission
and the High Representative have proposed several measures to ensure that the EU’s industry is equipped to
deliver both in the short and long run.
41
Cyber Rapid Response Teams and Mutual Assistance in Cyber Security (CRRT), Cyber and Information
Domain Coordination Centre (CIDCC), Cyber Threats and Incident Response Information Sharing Platform
(CTIRISP), Cyber Ranges Federations (CRF), EU Cyber Academia and Innovation Hub (EU CAIH).
38
12
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents