priority attention, such as regular dialogue and voluntary information exchanges on existing and
emerging threats, national policy or doctrine, national views on how international law applies to
State use of ICTs, and national approaches to defining critical infrastructure and categorizin g
ICT-related incidents. Sharing of good practices in approaches to digital forensics and
investigation of malicious cyber incidents could both increase cooperation and build capacity.
The value of developing shared understanding of concepts and terminology was also highlighted
as a practical step for furthering international cooperation and building trust. Other such
measures included developing guidance on the implementation of CBMs, training for diplomats,
exchanging lessons on establishing and exercising secure crisis communication channels,
personnel exchanges, scenario-based exercises at the policy level as well as operational exercises
at the technical level between Computer Emergency Response Teams (CERTs) or Computer
Security Incident Response Teams (CSIRTs). National transparency measures, such as
voluntarily sharing responses to an implementation survey or issuing national declarations of
adherence to the framework for responsible State behaviour, are other avenues to build trust and
confidence regarding the intentions and commitments of States.
64. Taking into account the experiences of regional bodies with establishing and maintaining
Points of Contact (PoC) networks, and building on existing networks, the viability of establishing
a central global directory of PoCs was discussed. At the same time, it was noted that the security
of such a directory as well as its operational modalities would be crucial to its effectiveness, as
would avoiding duplicative or overly detailed arrangements. The value of regularly conducting
exercises among a network of PoCs was also emphasized, as it can help to maintain readiness
and responsiveness and ensure that PoC directories remain updated.
65. As CBMs can be developed at the bilateral, regional or multilateral levels, States also
discussed the desirability and viability of establishing a global repository of CBMs under the
auspices of the United Nations, with the objective of sharing policy, good practice, experiences
and assessments of CBM implementation, and encouraging peer learning and investment in
capacity-building. Such a repository could also assist States to identify additional CBMs
appropriate to their national and regional contexts and offer potential models for adaptation
elsewhere. It was noted that any new global repository should not duplicate existing
arrangements and that operational modalities would need to be further discussed.
66. States also drew attention to the roles and responsibilities of other actors, including civil
society, the private sector, academia and the technical community, in contributing to building
trust and confidence in the use of ICTs at the national, regional and global levels. States noted
the variety of multi-stakeholder initiatives that, through the development of principles and
commitments, have established new networks for exchange, collaboration and cooperation. In a
similar vein, sector- or domain-specific initiatives have demonstrated the growing awareness of
the roles and responsibilities of other actors and the unique contributions that they can make to
ICT security through voluntary commitments, professional codes and standards.
Conclusions and Recommendations
67. States agreed that the dialogue within the Open-ended Working Group was in itself a CBM,
as it stimulates an open and transparent exchange of views on perceptions of threats and
vulnerabilities, responsible behaviour of States and other actors and good practices, thereby
ultimately supporting the collective development and implementation of the framework for
responsible State behaviour in their use of ICTs.
12
Commented [A25]: Transfer para 66 to conclusions
section if discussion sections are deleted
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents